When you buy into a community with a homeowner's association (HOA), you're investing in a collective promise-a promise of stewardship, openness, and responsibility. And when that promise is broken, not only does it terrify residents, but it leads to tough questions about how we protect our neighborhoods. The case of Jay Marshall Cain, the former treasurer of the Provincial Park Homeowners Association in Carrollton, Georgia, is just such a wake-up call.
Jay Cain, 77, was taken into custody and charged with theft by conversion and second-degree forgery after an investigation showed he allegedly used thousands of dollars in HOA funds for personal expenses between 2022 and 2025. Investigators also accuse Cain of second-degree forgery between 2022 and 2025.
It ain't over yet, but for all of us who reside in HOAs, the message has already been delivered: governing communities must be more than manageable-it must be safe, ethical, and open.
A Wake-Up Call for HOAs Everywhere
Wherever you may be, in Carrollton or Crisfield, or somewhere else nationally, this sort of affront resonates. As HOA board members, vendors, and community management professionals, we do not just have financial responsibilities, but moral responsibilities as well. When that responsibility shortchanges someone, it impacts all homeowners who pay fees, go to meetings, and have faith in the system.
Consider writing a check to your HOA dues each month, thinking that the funds are being used for landscaping, roadwork, security enhancements, or community events-only to find that the treasurer has probably been using the funds on his or her own account. Not only is it maddening; it's betrayal.
The Provincial Park case is not the first to put an HOA board member in the dock on charges of embezzlement, but it's a grim reminder that in-house checks and balances are not optional.
What Went Wrong?
Not all the facts are in yet, but early reports are that Cain manipulated financial statements and unauthorized withdrew funds from HOA accounts for three years. That is an awfully long time for abuse to go on and nobody notices.
Which leaves one with some questions:
Were there no treasurer audits?
Who signed off on the treasurer's reports?
Was there a rule that two must sign off on financial dealings?
In most small HOAs, there is a common practice wherein one board member handles money with little constraint-not because they're careless, but by convenience or habit. To their detriment, this opens the floodgates to extreme risk.
How HOAs Can Protect Themselves
We at Saunders HOA are leaders in taking proactive management measures like financial transparency measures that minimize the possibility of fraud. Some best practices that all HOAs need to consider are outlined below:
1. Two Signatures on every Check
No one person should have complete authority over the HOA's bank account. Having two signatures gives an extra layer of protection.
2. Monthly Financial Reporting
Require itemized monthly budget statements at each board meeting. And don't just report-review and discuss them.
3. Annual Third-Party Audits
Even with this small of a community, an outside audit once annually is a worthwhile investment. It finds problems before they become major ones and provides reassurance.
4. Open Communication with Homeowners
Too often, HOAs make finances “board only.” That breeds secrecy. Distribute quarterly financial reports to all homeowners.
5. Access-Controlled Computer Accounting Systems
Use modern HOA management software that tracks every transaction, limits access by function, and provides an audit trail. Goodbye, those old ledger books.
6. Professional Management Services
Most HOAs can do a big favor to themselves by employing the services of a professional such as Saunders HOA. We offer financial controls, board education, compliance, and integrity in everything that we do.
Human Side of HOA Mismanagement
It's not so hard to come up with numbers such as this and violations of law, such as this, but something deeply human hangs in the balance here, too. Neighbors surely knew Jay Cain, the person, personally. He was their neighbor, buddy, fellow citizen with whom people felt okay they could trust.
In close-knit communities, friendships create a sense of unease to ask tough questions or to impose processes. We don't want to offend a volunteer who donates time. But duty without trust is not stewardship-it's a flaw.
What You Can Do Today
If you're a homeowner or board member, here's how you can improve today:
Ask Questions: It's all right to ask where money is being spent.
Attend Board Meetings: Your voice counts. Involvement begins with attendance.
Review Governing Documents: Familiarize yourself with your HOA's by laws and fiscal policies.
Request Financial Transparency: Ask respectfully for regular statements and reports.
Champion Professional Management: Encourage experienced HOA management.
If your community is strained or unsure, we can help. Saunders HOA's emphasis is building ethical, transparent, and responsive community governance. We offer board education, budget support, and full-service management with the resident in mind. Conclusion: Trust Is Earned and Protected
The case of Jay Marshall Cain is still under investigation. There may be more to the story, and we’ll respect the process. But it’s a powerful reminder of how fragile trust can be-and how essential it is to protect the systems that hold our communities together.
We believe HOAs should be a source of pride, not stress. And that begins with professional, accountable leadership and management.
Want to talk with us regarding improving your community's financial management? Phone 336-937-6275 Saunders HOA today and let's strengthen your community, making it safer, more secure.
Welcome to Saunders HOA Management, LLC 336-937-6275 info@SRealtyNow.com
Lessons from the Jay Cain HOA Fund Misuse Case
Our Links
Contact Us
We provide peace of mind for HOA Boards through communication and transparency.
© 2023 Saunders HOA Management, LLC
Mail Address: 2806 Reynolda Rd. MB# 223 Winston-Salem, NC 27106